Clus­ter Hea­da­ches: The Role of Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Dys­func­tion and the Effec­ti­ve­ness of Prism Glas­ses

Do you suf­fer from epi­so­dic or chro­nic clus­ter hea­da­ches?
Have doc­tors been unable to iden­ti­fy a clear cau­se despi­te num­e­rous exami­na­ti­ons — and the usu­al the­ra­pies sim­ply do not bring las­ting reli­ef?
Are you loo­king for an effec­ti­ve, medi­ca­ti­on-free solu­ti­on that addres­ses the root of your sym­ptoms?

Then you are in the right place. For many pati­ents, a key trig­ger for their clus­ter hea­da­ches lies whe­re almost no one thinks to look: in bino­cu­lar visi­on.

For a signi­fi­cant num­ber of peo­p­le, clus­ter hea­da­ches are trig­ge­red by a bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion (BVD) — also known as bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment or hete­ro­pho­ria. This mis­a­lignment cau­ses sym­ptoms only during two-eyed (bino­cu­lar) visi­on and can trig­ger clus­ter hea­da­che attacks. It is not a dise­a­se, but a mus­cu­lar imba­lan­ce in the eye move­ment sys­tem.

Many affec­ted indi­vi­du­als noti­ce that their clus­ter attacks decrease signi­fi­cant­ly when one eye is cover­ed with a soft, com­ple­te­ly light-blo­cking eye patch for seve­ral days.
The reason: cove­ring one eye tem­po­r­a­ri­ly eli­mi­na­tes the need to com­pen­sa­te for the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment — and thus remo­ves the pain-trig­ge­ring sti­mu­lus. As a result, clus­ter hea­da­ches typi­cal­ly dimi­nish after a few days.
This clear and repro­du­ci­b­le effect has con­vin­ced even strong skep­tics that, in many peo­p­le, clus­ter hea­da­ches are trig­ge­red by an unde­tec­ted bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion.

For this reason, pati­ents with clus­ter hea­da­ches from many count­ries have come to me to have their bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment cor­rec­ted. After being fit­ted with indi­vi­du­al­ly adjus­ted prism glas­ses, more than 80 pati­ents have recor­ded per­so­nal vide­os to share their expe­ri­en­ces and help inform others suf­fe­ring from clus­ter hea­da­ches.

You can find the­se tes­ti­mo­ni­als here:

The First Step Toward Pain Reli­ef for Many Pati­ents: The Eye Patch Test

You may still be skep­ti­cal at this point — and that is com­ple­te­ly under­stan­da­ble.
You do not need to book an appoint­ment with me right away or take on a long jour­ney.
You can first test for yours­elf whe­ther your clus­ter hea­da­ches are actual­ly trig­ge­red by bino­cu­lar visi­on or a bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment (hete­ro­pho­ria).

The simp­lest way to do this is with a medi­cal eye patch test. Detail­ed ins­truc­tions can be found here: Eye Patch Test for Clus­ter Hea­da­ches.

Important: Plea­se make sure to use a soft, ful­ly light-blo­cking medi­cal eye patch that does not press on or touch the pain­ful eye.

Many peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches report that wea­ring the eye patch con­ti­nuous­ly for seve­ral hours or days leads to typi­cal chan­ges:

  • The pres­su­re sen­sa­ti­on around the pain­ful eye decrea­ses after a few hours. Many pati­ents had not noti­ced this pres­su­re any­mo­re becau­se it was con­stant­ly pre­sent. After remo­ving the patch, the uncom­for­ta­ble pres­su­re often returns imme­dia­te­ly.
  • Pain at the temp­le on the clus­ter hea­da­che side often impro­ves, as do neck ten­si­ons and light sen­si­ti­vi­ty.
  • As time goes on, the stab­bing or pul­ling pain around the eye subs­i­des — the clus­ter hea­da­che attacks beco­me wea­k­er and less fre­quent.

If you noti­ce the­se chan­ges, it is a strong indi­ca­ti­on that:
Your clus­ter hea­da­ches are very likely trig­ge­red by a bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion (hete­ro­pho­ria).
This also appli­es to night­ti­me attacks, which are then trig­ge­red during REM sleep. More on this later.

Important to know: The test does not work for ever­yo­ne, nor does it work at the same speed for all pati­ents. Around 70% noti­ce impro­ve­ment within a few hours up to three days. For others, it takes lon­ger — some­ti­mes up to two weeks. If you do not feel signi­fi­cant impro­ve­ment after seve­ral days, this does not mean that no bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment is pre­sent. The­re are many cases in which clus­ter hea­da­ches were com­ple­te­ly resol­ved with prism glas­ses even when the eye patch test did not show an obvious effect. In such situa­tions, the visi­ble mis­a­lignment of the pain­ful eye can be an important clue.

The Visi­ble Mis­a­lignment of the Pain­ful Eye

Ano­ther clear and meaningful way to iden­ti­fy a con­nec­tion bet­ween bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion (hete­ro­pho­ria) and clus­ter hea­da­ches is a visi­ble mis­a­lignment of the affec­ted eye.

Many peo­p­le suf­fe­ring from clus­ter hea­da­ches show a visi­ble ver­ti­cal devia­ti­on of the pain­ful “clus­ter eye.” This means the affec­ted eye sits slight­ly hig­her or lower com­pared to the other eye. In ever­y­day lan­guage, this is some­ti­mes refer­red to as a “stra­bis­mus” or “wan­de­ring eye.”

This visi­ble devia­ti­on is a strong indi­ca­tor of a ver­ti­cal bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment — and the­r­e­fo­re of a func­tion­al imba­lan­ce in the eye move­ment mus­cles.

If you are unsu­re, you can:

  • ask someone to take a clo­se look at your eye ali­gnment, or
  • send me a pho­to of your eye area at info@richtig-sehen.de.

In most cases, I can alre­a­dy see from a pho­to whe­ther a ver­ti­cal hete­ro­pho­ria (ver­ti­cal mis­a­lignment) is pre­sent.

All peo­p­le who came to me with clus­ter hea­da­ches after a posi­ti­ve eye patch test had one thing in com­mon:
The pain­ful eye devia­ted slight­ly upward or down­ward com­pared to the other eye.

Binocular Vision Dysfunction (BVD) can trigger cluster headaches
Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Dys­func­tion (BVD) can trig­ger clus­ter hea­da­ches

For exam­p­le: You may noti­ce in the pho­to that the left eye (from the per­spec­ti­ve of the per­son shown) devia­tes slight­ly upward com­pared to the other eye.
This is the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment /​ bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion (hete­ro­pho­ria) that the pain­ful eye must con­stant­ly com­pen­sa­te for with its eye mus­cles. When this mis­a­lignment is pre­cis­e­ly cor­rec­ted with prism glas­ses, the con­ti­nuous mus­cu­lar strain is remo­ved — and this is exact­ly why so many peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches expe­ri­ence a signi­fi­cant reduc­tion in their sym­ptoms, in most cases even com­ple­te free­dom from pain.

Why a Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Mis­a­lignment Can Trig­ger Clus­ter Hea­da­ches

Abo­ve the eye lies the troch­lea, a small ten­don sheath through which one of the eye move­ment mus­cles pas­ses and func­tions like a pul­ley. In oph­thal­mo­lo­gy, this struc­tu­re is also refer­red to as the supe­ri­or obli­que pul­ley or car­ti­la­ge ring. It is high­ly sen­si­ti­ve to con­ti­nuous mecha­ni­cal strain.

Exact­ly this type of strain occurs when a ver­ti­cal bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment (ver­ti­cal hete­ro­pho­ria) is pre­sent: the pain­ful eye sits slight­ly hig­her or lower than the other. This mini­mal dif­fe­rence is enough for both eyes to “look” at slight­ly dif­fe­rent points. To still pro­du­ce a sin­gle, uni­fied image, the eye move­ment mus­cle of the affec­ted eye must con­stant­ly com­pen­sa­te and pull the eye into the cor­rect posi­ti­on.

You can ima­gi­ne it like a rub­ber band kept under ten­si­on all day long: the eye wants to remain in its slight­ly off­set res­t­ing posi­ti­on, but the mus­cle must con­ti­nuous­ly cor­rect it upward or down­ward so that bino­cu­lar visi­on can func­tion.

This per­ma­nent mus­cu­lar effort can lead to an inflamm­a­ti­on of the troch­lea — simi­lar to a ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on in the hand or arm. This, in turn, pro­du­ces stab­bing, pul­ling, or dril­ling pain — exact­ly the type of pain that peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches typi­cal­ly descri­be.

The­re are also indi­ca­ti­ons from pain medi­ci­ne sug­gest­ing that the trig­ger for clus­ter hea­da­ches does not ori­gi­na­te in the brain but direct­ly in the area of the eye. Prof. Dr. Hart­mut Göbel from the Pain Cli­nic in Kiel wri­tes: “…it is likely that clus­ter hea­da­che ari­ses in struc­tures around or behind the eye.”

Nevert­hel­ess, in neu­ro­lo­gy the cau­se of clus­ter hea­da­ches is tra­di­tio­nal­ly sought pri­ma­ri­ly in the brain. This con­tra­dicts both what Prof. Göbel descri­bes and what many pati­ents con­sis­t­ent­ly report: clus­ter hea­da­che feels as if it ori­gi­na­tes direct­ly in the eye.

Indi­ca­ti­ons That an Infla­med Troch­lea May Be the Trig­ger for Clus­ter Hea­da­ches

Seve­ral striking par­al­lels sug­gest that a ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on in the regi­on of the eye — spe­ci­fi­cal­ly in the troch­lea — may inde­ed be the under­ly­ing trig­ger for clus­ter hea­da­ches:

  • Iden­ti­cal pain pat­terns: Both clus­ter hea­da­ches and ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­ons can occur epi­so­dical­ly (in pha­ses) or chro­ni­cal­ly (per­sis­t­ent­ly), depen­ding on whe­ther the mecha­ni­cal strain con­ti­nues.
  • Same pain cha­rac­te­ristics: The pain during a clus­ter hea­da­che attack is stab­bing and pul­ling — exact­ly the same cha­rac­te­ristics seen in clas­sic ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on.
  • Cor­ti­so­ne is effec­ti­ve in both con­di­ti­ons: Cor­ti­so­ne is known to be an effec­ti­ve tre­at­ment for ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­ons — and for the same reason, it also helps reli­e­ve clus­ter hea­da­che sym­ptoms.
  • Pain point direct­ly at the troch­lea: Many pati­ents report that the most inten­se pain is loca­ted direct­ly abo­ve the eye — the exact loca­ti­on of the troch­lea.
  • Ten­der­ness and rest­ric­ted eye move­ment: The upper inner cor­ner of the eye is often pres­su­re-sen­si­ti­ve, and the pain­ful eye fre­quent­ly shows redu­ced mobi­li­ty, espe­ci­al­ly when loo­king up or down. The­se are also typi­cal signs of ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on.
  • Visi­ble signs of inflamm­a­ti­on: The pain­ful area is often red, swol­len, and warm to the touch — coo­ling pro­vi­des reli­ef in both con­di­ti­ons.
  • Strict­ly one-sided pain: Clus­ter hea­da­ches are always uni­la­te­ral — just like a ver­ti­cal bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment only strains one eye. Only that eye deve­lo­ps the cha­rac­te­ristic pain.
  • Eye patch con­firms the mecha­nism: When an eye patch remo­ves the strain cau­sed by the mis­a­lignment, clus­ter hea­da­ches impro­ve after a few days. Once the patch is remo­ved, the pain often returns imme­dia­te­ly. This is fur­ther evi­dence in each indi­vi­du­al case that the pain trig­ger lies in bino­cu­lar visi­on (a bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment).
  • Hor­mo­n­al influen­ces: During pregnan­cy, many women report fewer attacks — likely due to increased pro­ges­te­ro­ne levels, which have anti-inflamm­a­to­ry effects and may also redu­ce inflamm­a­ti­on in the troch­lea.

Addi­tio­nal­ly: The troch­lea is loca­ted out­side the brain, yet very clo­se to it. The ner­ve con­nec­tions in this area are extre­me­ly short — which explains why the pain is per­cei­ved so inten­se­ly and often “radia­tes across the enti­re face.”

The Heal­ing Pro­cess: What Hap­pens When the Strain Is Remo­ved with Prism Glas­ses

When the strain on the troch­lea is reli­e­ved by cor­rect­ly fit­ted prism glas­ses, the infla­med ten­don sheath can begin to heal. Many pati­ents the­r­e­fo­re report impro­ve­ments in a typi­cal sequence:

  • first, a reduc­tion in pres­su­re around the affec­ted eye
  • then, a decrease in temp­le and neck pain
  • fol­lo­wed by incre­asing­ly fewer attacks
  • and final­ly — with con­ti­nuous reli­ef — com­ple­te free­dom from pain

This heal­ing pro­cess is exact­ly the same as with any other ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on:
as long as the mecha­ni­cal strain per­sists, the pain per­sists as well.
Once the strain is remo­ved, the inflamm­a­ti­on can heal.

This also appli­es to the troch­lea — regard­less of whe­ther you expe­ri­ence epi­so­dic or chro­nic clus­ter hea­da­ches.

Addi­tio­nal­ly, REM sleep plays an important role: rapid eye move­ments during REM sleep place par­ti­cu­lar­ly high stress on the troch­lea and can trig­ger night­ti­me attacks. Once the strain is eli­mi­na­ted during the day through prism glas­ses and the troch­lea beg­ins to heal, day­ti­me attacks usual­ly dis­ap­pear first — fol­lo­wed by night­ti­me attacks.

Prism Glas­ses for Clus­ter Hea­da­ches: Spe­cia­li­zed Mea­su­re­ment & Gua­ran­tee

If the eye patch test — and pos­si­bly a visi­ble ver­ti­cal mis­a­lignment — indi­ca­te a bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion in your case, the next step is a pre­cise mea­su­re­ment in my prac­ti­ce.

A writ­ten regis­tra­ti­on is requi­red for this. You can find all infor­ma­ti­on here: Cont­act & Appoint­ment.

I have been working for many years with my own mea­su­re­ment and cor­rec­tion metho­do­lo­gy, which is fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fe­rent from the con­tro­ver­si­al MKH/H­aa­se-method.This approach is the result of deca­des of spe­cia­liza­ti­on exclu­si­ve­ly in bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tions — inclu­ding tho­se that trig­ger clus­ter hea­da­ches.

Becau­se this metho­do­lo­gy allows me to eli­mi­na­te all known risks asso­cia­ted with MKH prism cor­rec­tions, I offer every clus­ter hea­da­che pati­ent a gua­ran­tee of cor­rec­tion suc­cess: You only pay once the prism glas­ses are effec­ti­ve. I also gua­ran­tee that the prism values will not increase, but remain per­ma­nent­ly low.

I am able to pro­vi­de this gua­ran­tee becau­se hundreds of pati­ents have alre­a­dy come to me. The lar­ge num­ber of cases has given me extre­me­ly pre­cise prac­ti­cal know­ledge of how a bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment must be cor­rec­ted in order to relia­bly eli­mi­na­te clus­ter hea­da­ches.

Mis­dia­gno­ses Due to Insuf­fi­ci­ent Mea­su­re­ment Methods

Many peo­p­le who want to deter­mi­ne whe­ther a bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion is con­tri­bu­ting to their clus­ter hea­da­ches first turn to an oph­thal­mo­lo­gy prac­ti­ce. The­re, the sus­pi­ci­on is almost always dis­missed imme­dia­te­ly — often with state­ments such as “bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion doesn’t exist” or “that’s non­sen­se.”

Yet I have now work­ed with well over 200 indi­vi­du­als who­se bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion had pre­vious­ly been ruled out by an oph­thal­mo­lo­gist, even though it was cle­ar­ly pre­sent. The reason: the types of bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignments com­mon­ly asso­cia­ted with clus­ter hea­da­ches and migrai­ne are often so subt­le that they can­not be relia­bly detec­ted with stan­dard mea­su­re­ment methods used by most oph­thal­mo­lo­gists and many opti­ci­ans.

The result is a fre­quent mis­dia­gno­sis of “no bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion (BVD)”, with the unfort­u­na­te con­se­quence that the actu­al cau­se of the sym­ptoms remains undis­co­ver­ed.

Becau­se the expe­ri­en­ces of so many pati­ents are so con­sis­tent, I have been try­ing for years to initia­te a sci­en­ti­fic stu­dy exami­ning the con­nec­tion bet­ween bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion and clus­ter hea­da­ches. I would be wil­ling to pro­vi­de care for all par­ti­ci­pan­ts free of char­ge within such a stu­dy. So far, howe­ver, the­re has been no inte­rest from the neu­ro­lo­gi­cal field — even though many pati­ents no lon­ger requi­re medi­ca­ti­on after a pre­cise prism cor­rec­tion.

Expe­ri­en­ces from Other Pati­ents: Why Many Were Skep­ti­cal at First

It is enti­re­ly under­stan­da­ble if you still have doubts at this point. Most peo­p­le who now live nor­mal, pain-free lives initi­al­ly could not ima­gi­ne that their extre­me, stab­bing pain could have any­thing to do with bino­cu­lar visi­on — or that prism glas­ses could have any effect on clus­ter hea­da­ches.

But the expe­ri­en­ces of other pati­ents paint a very clear pic­tu­re. More than 80 indi­vi­du­als with dia­gno­sed epi­so­dic or chro­nic clus­ter hea­da­ches — all with con­firm­ed neu­ro­lo­gi­cal dia­gno­ses, many after stays in pain cli­nics such as Kiel or König­stein — have docu­men­ted their expe­ri­en­ces in vide­os.

Many were unable to work, reti­red due to their con­di­ti­on, and under enorm­ous emo­tio­nal and phy­si­cal strain. The­se peo­p­le are not try­ing to sell you any­thing. They want others to know that the­re is a way out — and that a cor­rect­ly fit­ted prism cor­rec­tion has hel­ped many of them far more than all pre­vious tre­at­ments and medi­ca­ti­ons com­bi­ned.

Here, four pati­ents share their sto­ries — each of whom beca­me pain-free with my prism glas­ses (vide­os in Ger­man):

You are curr­ent­ly vie­w­ing a pla­ce­hol­der con­tent from You­Tube. To access the actu­al con­tent, click the but­ton below. Plea­se note that doing so will share data with third-par­ty pro­vi­ders.

More Infor­ma­ti­on

You are curr­ent­ly vie­w­ing a pla­ce­hol­der con­tent from You­Tube. To access the actu­al con­tent, click the but­ton below. Plea­se note that doing so will share data with third-par­ty pro­vi­ders.

More Infor­ma­ti­on

You are curr­ent­ly vie­w­ing a pla­ce­hol­der con­tent from You­Tube. To access the actu­al con­tent, click the but­ton below. Plea­se note that doing so will share data with third-par­ty pro­vi­ders.

More Infor­ma­ti­on

You are curr­ent­ly vie­w­ing a pla­ce­hol­der con­tent from You­Tube. To access the actu­al con­tent, click the but­ton below. Plea­se note that doing so will share data with third-par­ty pro­vi­ders.

More Infor­ma­ti­on

You can find more tes­ti­mo­ni­als here:

Selbst­hil­fe­grup­pe Clus­ter­kopf­schmerz und Win­kel­fehl­sich­tig­keit

Sup­port Group: Clus­ter Hea­da­ches and Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Dys­func­tion

If you have ques­ti­ons or would like to con­nect with others affec­ted by clus­ter hea­da­ches, you are warm­ly invi­ted to join the Ger­man sup­port groups “Clus­ter­kopf­schmerz und Win­kel­fehl­sich­tig­keit” (Clus­ter Hea­da­ches and Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Dys­func­tion) on Face­book:

The­se groups were foun­ded seve­ral years ago by peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches who were not allo­wed to share their expe­ri­en­ces with prism glas­ses in gene­ral clus­ter hea­da­che forums — whe­re dis­cus­sions are often limi­t­ed exclu­si­ve­ly to medi­ca­ti­on-based tre­at­ments.

In the­se groups, things are dif­fe­rent: here, peo­p­le can open­ly dis­cuss what has tru­ly hel­ped them with their clus­ter hea­da­ches. Tog­e­ther, the two groups now have more than 850 mem­bers. You will find many indi­vi­du­als the­re who have beco­me per­ma­nent­ly pain-free with my prism glas­ses, who have been able to return to work, and who are once again able to live com­ple­te­ly nor­mal lives. The­se mem­bers are hap­py to ans­wer your ques­ti­ons — and I am also part of the group.

Important Notes on Mis­in­for­ma­ti­on and Prism Glas­ses Mea­su­red Using the MKH Method

In seve­ral lar­ge clus­ter hea­da­che forums, you may come across cri­ti­cal state­ments about prism glas­ses. Howe­ver, the­se state­ments app­ly exclu­si­ve­ly to prism glas­ses mea­su­red using the MKH /​ Haa­se method — the stan­dard pro­ce­du­re used by almost all oph­thal­mo­lo­gists and opti­ci­ans in Ger­ma­ny, Aus­tria, and Switz­er­land. This is not the pro­ce­du­re I use.

I work with my own mea­su­re­ment metho­do­lo­gy, which eli­mi­na­tes all known risks and dis­ad­van­ta­ges asso­cia­ted with MKH/​Haase prisms. Many pati­ents who come to me have pre­vious­ly had nega­ti­ve expe­ri­en­ces with “incor­rect” or unsui­ta­ble MKH prism glas­ses — in some cases, they expe­ri­en­ced no impro­ve­ment, and in others, the­re was even con­cern about incre­asing prism values or fears of even­tual­ly nee­ding eye mus­cle sur­gery. This risk is one of the main cri­ti­cisms of the MKH method and is regu­lar­ly dis­cus­sed by many oph­thal­mo­lo­gists. Howe­ver, it is important to under­stand:

The­se cri­ti­cisms can­not be appli­ed to all prism glas­ses — becau­se not all prism glas­ses are the same.

With my own mea­su­re­ment approach, I can ensu­re that the known risks asso­cia­ted with MKH/​Haase prisms do not occur. In all the­se years, I have never had a sin­gle case in which the prism values increased after my cor­rec­tion. For almost all pati­ents with clus­ter hea­da­ches, the total prism values remain below 2.00 prism diop­ters — a ran­ge in which the­re is abso­lut­e­ly no sur­gi­cal risk. Sur­gery for bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignments is only con­side­red start­ing at around 30.00 prism diop­ters per eye.

The­r­e­fo­re, I encou­ra­ge all pati­ents not to be unsett­led by gene­ral war­nings or dis­cus­sions in online forums. Ulti­m­ate­ly, what mat­ters is what works for you in ever­y­day life. This is exact­ly what I hear again and again from pati­ents who have expe­ri­en­ced the effect them­sel­ves: “Whoe­ver helps is right.”
Form your own opi­ni­on and make your decis­i­on based on your per­so­nal expe­ri­ence, not on gene­ral state­ments that do not app­ly to the prism glas­ses I pre­scri­be.

FAQ: Clus­ter Hea­da­ches, Bino­cu­lar Visi­on Dys­func­tion (BVD), and Prism Glas­ses

Here you will find ans­wers to fre­quent­ly asked ques­ti­ons about clus­ter hea­da­ches, bino­cu­lar visi­on dys­func­tion, and prism glas­ses:

Why Do Many Night­ti­me Attacks Occur During REM Sleep?

Renow­ned neu­ro­lo­gists such as Prof. Dr. Ste­fan Evers and Prof. Dr. Sven­ja Hap­pe report that clus­ter hea­da­che attacks occur par­ti­cu­lar­ly fre­quent­ly during REM sleep. In this sleep pha­se, the eyes move extre­me­ly quick­ly and abrupt­ly. The­se rapid move­ments place signi­fi­cant strain on the troch­lear ten­don sheath — the very struc­tu­re that is alre­a­dy overs­trai­ned in indi­vi­du­als with a bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment. As the night pro­gres­ses, REM pha­ses beco­me more inten­se. It is pre­cis­e­ly during the­se peri­ods that many pati­ents expe­ri­ence their most seve­re attacks. To me, this is a strong indi­ca­ti­on that the move­ment of the ten­don within the troch­lea may play a cen­tral role in trig­ge­ring night­ti­me clus­ter hea­da­che attacks.

Why Do Clus­ter Epi­so­des Often Begin in Autumn or Spring?

Many peo­p­le with epi­so­dic clus­ter hea­da­ches report that their epi­so­des typi­cal­ly start in autumn or spring. The­re are seve­ral reasons for this:

  • Fli­cke­ring light through bare trees: When the sun is low, dri­ving pro­du­ces inten­se fli­cke­ring light — a strong trig­ger.
  • Increased need for visu­al com­pen­sa­ti­on: To redu­ce gla­re, the “clus­ter eye” must com­pen­sa­te for the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment extre­me­ly well — signi­fi­cant­ly incre­asing the strain on the ten­don sheath.
  • Sinus inflamm­a­ti­ons: In autumn due to colds, in spring due to pol­len. Both increase the risk of inflamm­a­ti­on in the troch­lea.

For this reason, many of my epi­so­dic pati­ents wear their prism glas­ses con­sis­t­ent­ly even during pain-free peri­ods — becau­se they know they would other­wi­se very likely slip into the next epi­so­de.

Which Trig­gers Can Redu­ce the Eye Mus­cles’ Abili­ty to Com­pen­sa­te — and Thus Pro­mo­te Clus­ter Hea­da­che Attacks?

Many typi­cal clus­ter hea­da­che trig­gers beco­me easier to under­stand when you reco­gni­ze how inten­se­ly the eye move­ment mus­cles must work to com­pen­sa­te for a bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment. When­ever the­se mus­cles are wea­k­en­ed or must work excep­tio­nal­ly hard, the strain on the troch­lea increa­ses — and with it, the risk of an attack.

  • Alco­hol, for exam­p­le, rela­xes all mus­cles, which makes it har­der for the eyes to com­pen­sa­te for the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment. In extre­me cases, this can even lead to dou­ble visi­on — a com­mon imme­dia­te trig­ger for an attack.
  • Wea­ther chan­ges can nega­tively affect cir­cu­la­ti­on, over­all phy­si­cal well-being, and mus­cle tone — many pati­ents report an increase in attacks during such peri­ods.
  • Heat, hot baths, and sau­nas relax the eye mus­cles, redu­cing their abili­ty to com­pen­sa­te for the mis­a­lignment — attacks may be trig­ge­red.
  • Oxy­gen defi­ci­en­cy at hig­her alti­tu­des redu­ces the per­for­mance of all mus­cles, inclu­ding the eye move­ment mus­cles — often resul­ting in more clus­ter hea­da­che attacks.
  • Oxy­gen the­ra­py: Inha­ling pure oxy­gen increa­ses mus­cle per­for­mance, allo­wing the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment to be com­pen­sa­ted more effec­tively. Many pati­ents are able to shor­ten or even stop attacks using this method.
  • Phy­si­cal rest­less­ness and acti­vi­ty: Increased breathing during move­ment impro­ves oxy­gen sup­p­ly to the mus­cles. This also enhan­ces the per­for­mance of the eye move­ment mus­cles — many pati­ents report that they can over­co­me attacks more quick­ly, for exam­p­le by doing inten­se push-ups.
  • Coo­ling the eye area can posi­tively influence the mus­cles’ abili­ty to com­pen­sa­te and may help an attack subs­i­de more quick­ly.
  • Hun­ger or dehy­dra­ti­on wea­k­en over­all mus­cle per­for­mance — inclu­ding the abili­ty to com­pen­sa­te for the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment.
  • Ener­gy drinks, glu­co­se, or magne­si­um can increase mus­cle per­for­mance and may help pre­vent or redu­ce the seve­ri­ty of attacks.
  • Colds and other ill­nesses wea­k­en the mus­cu­la­tu­re and thus redu­ce com­pen­sa­ti­on abili­ty — clus­ter hea­da­ches often increase during such pha­ses.
  • Nap­ping: During sleep, all mus­cles relax, inclu­ding the eye move­ment mus­cles. When the eyes are ope­ned sud­den­ly, the mus­cles must con­tract abrupt­ly to com­pen­sa­te for the mis­a­lignment — this can trig­ger attacks right after fal­ling asleep or upon waking.
  • Fli­cke­ring light, bright light, TV, screen work, cine­ma: Inten­se light sti­mu­li and visual­ly deman­ding tasks force the eye mus­cles to com­pen­sa­te as com­ple­te­ly as pos­si­ble in order to impro­ve visu­al cla­ri­ty and redu­ce light sen­si­ti­vi­ty. This increa­ses the strain on the troch­lea — and may trig­ger attacks.
  • Stress nega­tively affects the mus­cles’ abili­ty to com­pen­sa­te and is the­r­e­fo­re a com­mon trig­ger for clus­ter hea­da­che attacks.

The con­stant ten­si­on in the eye mus­cles also affects ana­to­mic­al­ly con­nec­ted mus­cle groups — such as the temp­les, fore­head, jaw, and neck. Many pati­ents noti­ce that the­se are­as beco­me signi­fi­cant­ly more rela­xed once the bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment is cor­rec­ted with prism glas­ses.

Is Clus­ter Hea­da­che a Dise­a­se?

Many peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches expe­ri­ence pain of almost uni­ma­gi­nable inten­si­ty. Num­e­rous pati­ents — inclu­ding women who have expe­ri­en­ced both child­birth and clus­ter hea­da­ches — report that clus­ter hea­da­che pain is even stron­ger than labor pain.

Despi­te this extre­me level of pain, clus­ter hea­da­che is, in my view, not an inde­pen­dent dise­a­se. Rather, it beha­ves like a war­ning signal from the body — simi­lar to how labor pain is not a dise­a­se, but a reac­tion to a phy­sio­lo­gi­cal pro­cess.
Every pain has a cau­se. When that cau­se is remo­ved, clus­ter hea­da­ches usual­ly dis­ap­pear as well.

Based on my expe­ri­ence, each attack points to a spe­ci­fic mecha­ni­cal source of pain: a ten­don sheath inflamm­a­ti­on in the eye move­ment sys­tem abo­ve the affec­ted eye.
This inflamm­a­ti­on results from con­ti­nuous strain — cau­sed by a bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment (hete­ro­pho­ria) that must be com­pen­sa­ted during bino­cu­lar visi­on.

Seve­ral indi­ca­tors sup­port this con­nec­tion:

  • Impro­ve­ment with an eye patch: Many pati­ents report that their pain decrea­ses or even dis­ap­pears within one to three days when one eye is com­ple­te­ly cover­ed with a soft, light-blo­cking eye patch (see abo­ve). This is objec­ti­ve evi­dence that the pain trig­ger lies in bino­cu­lar visi­on — and the­r­e­fo­re in a mis­a­lignment that cau­ses sym­ptoms only when both eyes are open.
  • Visi­ble mis­a­lignment of the affec­ted eye: In most peo­p­le with clus­ter hea­da­ches, this mis­a­lignment is extern­al­ly visi­ble. The affec­ted eye sits slight­ly hig­her or lower than the other (see abo­ve). This visi­ble devia­ti­on is a clear sign of a ver­ti­cal mus­cu­lar imba­lan­ce.
  • Imme­dia­te reac­tion when prism glas­ses are remo­ved: Peo­p­le with chro­nic clus­ter hea­da­ches report that pain often returns within a short time after remo­ving effec­ti­ve prism glas­ses. In epi­so­dic pati­ents, remo­ving the glas­ses can trig­ger indi­vi­du­al attacks — or even initia­te a new epi­so­de. In both cases, the direct link bet­ween bino­cu­lar mis­a­lignment and clus­ter hea­da­che beco­mes unmist­aka­b­ly clear.
  • The striking “alco­hol test”: Many pati­ents expe­ri­ence seve­re attacks after drin­king alco­hol — as long as both eyes are open. Howe­ver, when the affec­ted eye is cover­ed with an eye patch, alco­hol can often be tole­ra­ted wit­hout trig­ge­ring an attack. Num­e­rous pati­ent reports con­firm this con­nec­tion. It is important, howe­ver, that the patch is worn for as long as the alco­hol remains acti­ve in the body.
  • No known dise­a­se beha­ves this way: The­re is no known medi­cal con­di­ti­on that dis­ap­pears sole­ly by cove­ring one eye or wea­ring prism glas­ses — and imme­dia­te­ly returns when they are remo­ved. Such a pat­tern cle­ar­ly con­tra­dicts the idea of an inde­pen­dent dise­a­se and stron­gly sup­ports a mecha­ni­cal cau­se of pain.

The­r­e­fo­re, clus­ter hea­da­che — espe­ci­al­ly after a posi­ti­ve eye patch test or when a visi­ble mis­a­lignment is pre­sent — should be unders­tood as a clear signal from the body. With every attack, it indi­ca­tes that a strain-caus­ing bino­cu­lar visi­on mis­a­lignment is pre­sent and needs to be cor­rec­ted. A las­ting and effec­ti­ve reli­ef is only pos­si­ble with a pre­cis­e­ly fit­ted pair of prism glas­ses, as they relia­bly eli­mi­na­te the strain in bino­cu­lar visi­on that trig­gers the pain.

Feel free to recom­mend this web­site to others: